Early warning for Burundi - It needs violence-prevention now!

Burundi - few people around the world know anything about, probably not even roughly where it is on the map. But the 9 million people of Burundi should be known for their remarkable peace process after a genocide in the 1990s that took about 300.000 lives. That is, if the media and politicians had ever had any focus on this country and not only on Rwanda, their “darling” north of Burundi.

These very days and hours the risk is increasing that the world will hear about Burundi, not because of its good aspects but because of its political instability, threatening to break out in countrywide violence.

Burundi is the third poorest country in the world with a GDP per capita of about $ 150 per year. It’s peace process was mediated by towering figures such as Tanzania’s then president Julius Nyerere, by Nelson Mandela and others. A power sharing arrangement was agreed upon among 17 armed fractions that had been fighting each other. That is, with the exception of Agathon Rwasa, the warlord of FNL, a riffraff military unit, that kept on for years to intimidate the people and the peace by firing rockets on the capital Bujumbura and elsewhere. Amateur politician as he seems to be, he didn’t understand the timing of the process and stood alone outside. He is connected with a series of serious crimes during the genocide and is known for using child soldiers. He finally agreed to lay down arms and join politics.

Contrary to Burundi, its sister country in all ways, Burundi has been forgotten by the world in spite of its overall good - but certainly far from perfect - record. Five years ago, successful and peaceful elections were held that brought Pierre Nkurunziza to the Presidency - also a former fighter but one who publicly apologized for what he did (after several members of his family had been killed); he is still rather popular throughout the country, a born-again Christian obsessed with football. He was used to get out among people without much security and talk and sing with them. I got a rather good impression of him during a conversation some years ago.

The other side of the coin is that during his regime there has been rampant corruption, little real progress, too little of the kind of leadership people want and need in such a country. On the other hand, there are good indicators now and the Burundi has joined the East African Community that will definitely be a benefit to it in years to come.

Burundi is lay back. The human rights record has improved and it has a few reliable and very competent civil society movements. Women have progressed but it is still and seriously gender-violent society. The media are way behind European and other African standard but there is little clamping down by the government compared to many other countries, not the least Rwanda. The news these days coming out of Rwanda prior to its August elections also give reason for serious concern. Mr. Kagame however is the darling of the West, continues to do some dirty jobs in DR Congo and has the support of leading Western governments who always place human rights way below their strategic and economic interests.

Elections is also the key word to the present quite volatile situation in Burundi. This summer it is scheduled to hold elections at five levels. In late May the first local elections were held and deemed fair and free under the circumstances by both the tiny UN mission in the country, by EU observers and by the NGO Coalition for the Elections, run by very competent people.

Everybody agree that the organization of the first elections left a lot to be desired; they were postponed two times over a weekend because ballots, voters’ lists etc. had not reached their different stations throughout the bush. So, undoubtedly, the elections were not perfect, but rather mis-managed - as so much else in Burundi. If you want a nutshell description of the government’s infrastructure, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs - I was told last year - had one computer connected with the Internet and then there are frequent electricity cuts and lack of water for periods to produce electricity...

However, opposition leaders have complained that these elections which ended with 64% to the governing party, were the result of rampant, countrywide and systematic fraud. As far as I know no solid evidence of exactly that has been delivered to the National Commission that overseas the elections and their claim has found no support abroad.

I doubt the substance too. To rig elections and make the manipulation invisible to yur people, civil servants and international observers you need a very efficient organization into every corner of a country, something like a dictatorship. Burundi’s governing party simply does not have that capacity. A government that cannot get the ballots out in time is hardly able to systematically manipulate elections results and do it in a way that makes it look like everything is OK. But irregularities here and there - sure!

The opposition parties have decided to boycott the next elections - that of the President on June 28. Nkurunziza is, therefore, the only candidate. The only thing the opposition can possibly have in common is that they don’t like the government; you could hardly find two more different characters than war criminal Agathon Rwasa and brilliant journalist Alexis Sinduhije. And quite predictably they have not issued anything like an alternative program and there is no way you could imagine them working together as a government.

There has been several small-scale instances of local violence, mostly against offices of the ruling party. Some innocent people have been killed. The minister of defence expresses his deep concern of what could be looming around the corner. UN S-G Ban Ki Moon came by for a few hours lately and spoke with no effect - boring to the Moon, you may say.

There is a fairly big risk now that hotheads will instigate violence at poll stations. With a bad economic situation for most of the people, there isn’t much to lose. In countries such as Burundi, it only takes a few politicians and the manipulation of young, uneducated people to start a fire that no one will eventually be able to control, let alone put out.

Here is a case that demonstrates how woefully ill equipped the so-called international community remains in spite of all assertions to the contrary. Leading international figures could threaten - not sanctions on the people, but - abrogation of all but humanitarian assistance if war breaks out (the international community has anyhow never met even 50% of its assistance pledge!).

But much better would be to promise massive international support in various ways if the opposition gives up its destructive stance and to demand, if necessary, that a considerable international African and/or UN police force + civil affairs mission be deployed as soon as humanly possible. Nkurunziza and the government has asked most of the UN to leave, claining that it could now do on its own. If it can’t, there is all reason to negotiate a return - a large return but without military component.

The rule of thumb is: Start early and the fire can be prevented or may be manageable both locally and internationally. Start late and we may see another genocide. Objectively speaking, it would only harm 99,99% of the people.

And that is my final point. The people of Burundi do not want, even for one hour, to see another bout of killings, rapes and genocidal madness. They’ve had enough. I travelled around the country now and then over the last ten years, and if you ask people what they want for the future, they don’t first mention new clothes, a house, good school for their children or a car. No - they say, peace and peace and peace again. And they deserve it. They need safety, education, health, environmental care, gender equality and everyting else that war can never bring. They need food - plain and simple.

And the international community has never lived up to its minimum responsibility vis-a-vis this country that has shown so much human progress against all odds.

The Burundians have managed to live rather peacefully together again, using ancient village rituals and other means to dialogue and accommodate their mad recent history, to switch houses back and forth in order to welcome back refugees from neighbouring countries. I’ve seen much more tolerance and forgiveness - perhaps also because of their deep faith - than I have seen anywhere in former Yugoslavia (that has received billions of dollars and huge international attention). I’ve had taught and worked with youth - university as well as street kids - and they give me a sense of hope for the future.

Burundi’s situation is now very fragile, perhaps dangerous. We don’t know it. But it would be utterly stupid if the international community does not step in and DO something to prevent another war. I hope my early warning here will turn out to be wrong and everything will go well. Even so, better be on the safe side and commit massive violence-prevention today than having to see 10 years of peace-building nullified by a few amateur hotheads and a new war that will set back the country another 20 years. The thought is unbearable to me!

Perhaps you believe that I support the government. I don’t. Neither do I support the opposition. These are irrelevant positions. My judgement is that it is the welfare and peace for the 9 million people rather than the short-sighted games of elites that should count. That is why Burundi today needa the attention of BBC an CNN and Aljazeera and of capable, serious international organisations.

However, if I imagine that I am a Burundian farmer with five kids, I think I would would vote for the present ruling party and President Nkurunziza - in spite of all the evident, serious shortcomings - because the opposition has already shown that it has nothing more constructive to offer than obstruction and, potentially, destabilization. That is as irresponsible as it is dangerous in the midst of a very complex peace process inside a country that is seeing only the embryo of democracy for the first time.

With my love of this country and its people, I cannot but write this early warning to anyone who cares to listen: Please do violence-prevention now! Please help keep Burundi on its track to peace and democracy. Please put the needs of the 9 million citizens on top of your agenda! And remember it is cheaper and more effective to do prevention today than doing repair work the next 20 or so years!


Jan Oberg
TFF director

Jan Oberg has been in an out of Burundi for the last 11 years working with civil society organisations, the Ministry of Higher Education, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and today with street kids and the Amahoro Youth Club.

Views: 91

Comment

You need to be a member of Peace and Collaborative Development Network to add comments!

Join Peace and Collaborative Development Network

Comment by Eric SHIMA on April 28, 2011 at 5:06am

Dear Jan Oberg,

Although I react later, I still think it's worth reading your warning about peace in Burundi. Yes some positions might not be shared with majority in Burundi  - not  necessarily beacuse they are wrong but beacuase your outsider's view has chances to be more objective beyond the passion of insiders - but the flow of your ideas demonstrates the sincerity of your engagement and your style makes the honesty evident. Clarity and openess are the windows to enter your paper. Admirable. I fact some declarations, claiming to be neutral, fail to lead to aconcrete actions because there is no any clear position on some facts  of the field, what renders the situation hazy and , in some cases, more complicate.. I would add that, from my own experience, to commit TRULY our peace programmes into the hands of the almighty Jesus is the way of overcoming . This requires to host the Lord Jesus Christ as   King and a Savior in an authentic way. Jesus is most peacbuilder we have. Ignoring this fact is the most stupid  way a human being can take to reach peace.  I wish you to be lead by the Holy Spirit to leave intellectual speculations and understand this point. I have an MPHil in International peace studies from Trinity College Dublin but have come to understand the power of Jesus in the matter of a genuine peace. Pray then and read  John in the Bible.

Best

Eric SHIMA

Comment by William Tayeebwa on July 27, 2010 at 12:58am
On the controversial issue of "election rigging", the Burundi media under the "Synergy" ought to be lauded. In most African countries, most mass media outlets are often used in a very unbalanced manner during elections to favor the incumbent. In Burundi, media initiatives notably by Studio Ijambo and BINUP have played a central role in curbing incendiary rhetoric that often fuels violence. http://binub.turretdev.com/en/index.php?option=com_content&task...
Comment by Niyongabo Jean Baptiste on July 5, 2010 at 11:33am
If the World does really evaluate the expenses in human resources an material spent over countries like Burundi,it cannot allow the worst to happen again. The contribution of the African Union, the United nations, the European Union and other individual countries in the peace process in Burundi shouldn't fall down like that. If we help to such an extent and then keep our hands in our pockets when there are burning houses in front of our eyes,it means that our help was ironical. There are many ways to prevent all bad events since no country is walking alone in the world system. Everything is under control except when we close our eyes and ears.
Comment by Sani musa on July 4, 2010 at 11:43pm
The observations made by Mr Orbeg are very important and should be taken seriously. this kind of warning have in the pass ignored until violent erupt. It is often said that let make hay while the sun shines. we should not allow the sun to set leaving what we should do during the day and go looking for lantern in the night to do what we should have done during the day. It clear that the problem of Burindi is that of poverty been the 3rd poorest country in the world. The country at the moment need massive international presence, UNESCO presence and other NGO to take care of the educational sector. To solve this problem there should be a window for them to see a light at the end of the tunnel through empowering them with education. Provision of food alone cannot solve the problem. Let them have hope future so that they guide themselves toward actualising that hope
Comment by John Mugisa on June 30, 2010 at 12:30pm
Yesterday was presidential election in Burundi. I wonder if we can talk of democracy with one and unique candidate? Oberg, your article is an eye opener on what is going on in Burundi. Very inspirational
Comment by Telesphore Kagaba on June 29, 2010 at 6:20am
Hello Jan,
I participated in (all sessions of) the Arusha Peace Process for Burundi and saw its switch to South Africa. I was behind-the-scene participant as a (French - English) language expert. Later on, I was involved in classroom research (Graduate Peace Studies) on the country. Indeed, a lot needs to be done for the country and the Great Lakes Region of Africa.

Telesphore Kagaba.
Comment by Rosebell Kagumire on June 28, 2010 at 1:26pm
Comment by Henry on June 28, 2010 at 12:47pm
Thanks Jan for this early warning piece. I happen to be among the people that participated in the election that brought in President Nkurunziza to power in 2005. I worked in Bujumbura, Bururi province and 4 of its communes-Rumonge,Burambi, Buyengero and Vyanda and Ruyugi province and all its communes- Bweru, Gisuru, Butezi, Butaganzwa Kiyinya and Nyabistinda. i lived in Bujumbura for 3 months, Rumonge 6 Months and Ruyugi 3 months so i have a good knowledge of the situation in Burundi. Just like Jan said, i can categorically say that Burundians would not like to experience any form of violence again, never again. Let me seize this opportunity to commend Jan's effort for this early warning,this warning should not just be negleted, my advise is that let all Burundians rally round those in position of authority and work together to ensure that the present situation does not deteriorate to something else. My brother, Niyongabo Jean Baptiste, Bite, ni sawa? Please do not be tired of the good work you are doing, continue to educate the youths on the need to maintain peace in Burundi, i Commend your effort, and may God give you more strength and resources to propagate this message. Therefore, as Burundians go the polls this morning, to elect their president, we pray for a peaceful and successful election. Thanks. Henry Yurkusi
Comment by Rosebell Kagumire on June 28, 2010 at 12:43pm
"However, opposition leaders have complained that these elections which ended with 64% to the governing party, were the result of rampant, countrywide and systematic fraud. As far as I know no solid evidence of exactly that has been delivered to the National Commission that overseas the elections and their claim has found no support abroad."

Thanks for the insight into what is going in Burundi and the politics but i find your comment about election rigging not entirely true. No one abroad seems to understand how elections are riggid in Africa. I have been a journalist in Uganda and I have seen enough reports from the so called elections observers clean and with no idea where the election is stolen.
To say that a government that is incapable of distributing election materials to all corners is incapable of rigging is not good enough argument.
We have unlimited examples in Africa, elections remain just a way for regimes on the continent to legitimise themselves in the eyes of the west which is different to citizens on the continent.

I am not sayint that Burundi's election was an outright rigged one but i simply know that the abroad world doesn't know how elections are rigged in Africa. They only join the chorus of condemming one violence breaks out. Of course the civil society in Burundi is doing well but can they stop an election from being rigged no! And the UN do that I certainly don't think so.

The elections for most of us on the continent remain another way of entrenching dictatorship. I hope Burundi doesn't go the very low Kenyan and Zimbabwe road.
Comment by Abdulai Alhaji Sulley on June 28, 2010 at 12:40pm
Hello Jan Oberg,

Thank you for the courage and hard work you have shown. My humble plea to you is to send a copy of your message to the East African Organization of which Burundi is now a member. Secondly the African Union has a social network and I will send the message to the group.

I think we have had more than enough of the conflict and need to use the relative peace we have in places like Burundi as very sound foundation blocks for sustainable development.

Thank you once again Jan Oberg for the Early warning message, God bless you

Sponsored Link

Please Pay What You Can to Support PCDN

Please consider Paying What You Can to help PCDN grow. We encourage you to consider any amount from $1 and up. Read the SUPPORT page prior to making a payment to see PCDN's impact and how your payment will help.

Sponsored Link

Translate This Page



PCDN NETWORK TWITTER FEED

SHARE THIS PAGE and Follow the PCDN NETWORK

By using this site you're agreeing to the terms of use as outlined in the community guidelines. Please note individual requests for funding or jobs are NOT permitted on the network.

Click BELOW to share site resources

or Share on LINKEDIN


FOLLOW PCDN on TWITTER or FACEBOOK

 

© 2012   Created by Craig Zelizer.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service