Peace and Collaborative Development Network
Building Bridges, Networks and Expertise Across Sectors
Spread the word. Get your own Peace and Collaborative Development Network badge for your website or MySpace page. (Get Code)
© 2008 Created by czelizer
Comment Wall (8 comments)
You need to be a member of Peace and Collaborative Development Network to add comments!
Join this network
I have also found the idea of 'bounded groupness' interesting. I must give credit where it is due - it comes from a seminal article critiquing the 'identity' literature by Brubaker and Cooper: Brubaker, Rogers, and Frederick Cooper. 2000. Beyond 'Identity'. Theory and Society 29 (1):1-47.
If you haven't already come across it, it is definitely a worthwhile read.
As for the generational issues, I have tried to lay out some of my thinking on this, as well as a concept I call 'social age' in a forthcoming article in the Journal of International Development Studies. I could send you a copy (I'm not sure if I can attach a file to this message - I am fairly new at these internet-based networking sites), if you provide me with an email address.
Do keep in touch on your research!
Christina
Thanks for the prompt response, and for the links to your documents. You have introduced me to another level at which conflict/collaboration plays out: the generational level. I will certainly have to explore it also at some stage.
It seems also that all along I have been trying to look at, if I may call them, bounded groups (thanks for that too.. ) by taking ‘groupness’ as a given, and thinking about groups as pigeon holes in which to slot individuals. From your findings on group solidarity amongst the ‘Congolese’ you studied you reveal that ‘groupness’ is dynamic and situational. I now have to disabuse myself of the ill manners of pigeonholing and reflect also on factors that consolidate or fracture groups. After all, to the outside observer, Banyarwanda are one group, or Somali are a single national ‘group’, but when push comes to shove, they slash each other carotids. Yet of course, North Americans are a 'melting pot'...
Thanks for the insights.
Sabiiti
I think that your proposed research on intra-Hutu violence is very interesting and necessary. I agree that too much of the ethnic violence research tends to suggest 'bounded groupness', with the emphasis on the differences and animosity between groups, overlooking the heterogeneity and power dynamics within groups. I am particularly interested in inter- and intra-generational relationships within groups and my research has shown that these dynamics are complex, even at the level of daily life, not to mention when issues become politicized. In case this is of any use to you, you can download a paper I wrote on this issue, using network theory to problematize the way in which we often think about groups, at: http://www.hicn.org/papers/wp13.pdf
As for interaction with Hutu in Kyaka II, I did meet some, but my research was focused on Congolese refugees, so I had less contact with Rwandese, although many Congolese Hutu have historic familial ties to Rwanda. The majority of my research subjects in the settlement were Hema and Lendu from Ituri, or Chi from the Kivus. In terms of intra-ethnic relations generally, I found that people when they first arrived tended to seek out members of their ethnic groups, in many cases leaving their allocated plot of land in the settlement to move to areas where other people of their ethnicity lived. Another interesting finding on the identity issue was that migration tended to reinforce a sense of (ill-defined) Congolese nationality, even among those (including Hutu) who are perceived "not to belong" in the DRC (the so-called 'non-indigenous' groups). I have written up some of my findings in another article at: http://www.hicn.org/papers/wp38.pdf.
None of this is very Hutu-specific, so I don't know how helpful it will be. But, I look forward to keeping in touch on our on-going research on Great Lakes issues.
Christina
Thanks for the message. Indeed virtualness shrinks our little world. Much of my research is still embryonic, but it will shape up soon... One of the strands I am pursuing is intra-Hutu violence in pre-genocide Rwanda. All we tend to hear about is Hutu-Tutsi animosity but not the sectarian undercurrents that obtain within each of those two groups, at times causing murderous strife. You may have heard about the Northern Hutu Vs the Southern Hutu leading to the 1973 coup, then Northwestern Hutu vs Northeastern Hutu leading to the confusion of the early 1980s etc until the Hutu theselves got divided to the level of the commune and finally 'Akazu'. If you ave any hints on that sectarian fission please guide me. I am sure in Kyaka II you interacted with Hutu. I wonder whether they were one with each other. If you observed anything, please....
Nice to see you on this Network. I am from Nepal. Its great to here about experiences in venerable African country. Hope we will be in touch and we will share our experiences each others.
Thanks
Yadab
Cheers
looking ahead a Human Touch!!!!