Published on Countercurrents

The Supreme Court of India has recently recognised transgenders to be the third gender. They have been recognised as full citizens of the country who will be entitled to equal rights. This decision has been warmly welcomed by not just people of LGBTQ community but also by many amongst the heterosexual community. It is being seen as the realisation of a true and just democracy. It is being hailed as a progressive move.

However, I think that there is much more that the heterosexuals should derive out of this commendable judgement and the larger LGBTQ movement. This decision and the struggle for the equal rights should not just be seen and labelled as 'liberal' or 'progressive' by the heterosexuals. I always feel that the LGBTQ movement is a liberating experience not just for the people of non-heteronormative or diverse sexualities but for all genders. 

I consider it important to state that I claim no expertise in this matter. My understanding over the issue is based on basic scholarly literature and the little experience that I have had. In this article, I attempt to share the lessons that I derive from the LGBTQ movement. What it means to me.

The most basic lesson that I derive from the movement is in its very nature. The LGBTQ movement, as the name suggests, is not a homogeneous movement. There are many sub-groups within and they vary greatly in terms of their issues. The LGBTQ community represents and celebrates the diversity that nature has shown in everything including sexuality. Contrary to popular misconception, diverse forms of sexuality are natural. There are several forms of evidence available including the fact that diverse sexualities is present both in plant and animal kingdom. Theorists like Foucault have discussed how heteronormatity has come in a certain historical time in Europe. There are others who have shown how this was disseminated in different societies through colonialism. Other factors like religion, over-emphasis on fertility and several other social factors led to non-heteronormative sexualities being regarded as a deviant. The LGBTQ movement challenges this and brings to light the truth about the extent of diversity that nature has shown. The nature loves diversity in every aspect including sexuality. Heteorsexualty may appear more prominent but it is just one form of the diverse sexualities that are present in the nature. 

The LGBTQ movement is a movement of liberation for all. The LGBTQ movement not only challenges the heteronormative society but also the patriarchal society. This is because it challenges the notion of gender as determinants of behaviour. It challenges the gender-based roles and stereotypes. It challenges that sex and gender are natural. It proves that they are social constructions. While we are born with a particular genital, our behaviour, preferences has been constructed by the society. The society makes a man or a woman. It is the society that expects a person with a vagina to take care of the household. The LGBTQ movement disrupts all binary and opposing notions. It does so in several ways.

A homosexual person often challenges the stereotypes conforming to their gender. However, it must be noted that not all homosexuals will do so. A transgender female may be born with a penis but does not feel or consider herself to be a man. Then there is also the case of inter-sex people. They clearly transcend the binary notion of gender.

Another fundamental essence of the LGBTQ movement is the emphasis on individual agency. Who gets the right to decide whether a person is a man or a woman? They would say that the person himself/herself. I find it empowering and extend it beyond this. I see it as this beautiful idea of “I am what I think I am”. It talks about the self breaking the constructed barriers. It celebrates the individual that challenges the biased and discriminatory notions, norms constructed by the society. It gives importance to the individual’s perspective. It celebrates the voice against injustice and inequality.

To conclude, I think that the LGBTQ movement should be seen as the liberation of us all. It is a movement tied not just to the issue of sexuality. It is waging battles far beyond. It exposes the society and its norms that we take as “primordial” and “natural” as a construct. It encourages us to come out and speak against the injustice. It encourages us to be ourselves, to respect ourselves. 

Views: 115


You need to be a member of Peace and Collaborative Development Network to add comments!

Join Peace and Collaborative Development Network

Comment by Dr. Eliezah Titus on May 13, 2014 at 6:37am
Thank you, the reason we are so ignorant is simply because we are so arrogant and we always think we know what's right. We are so hypocritical that we've hidden the truth to please a few individuals, and we've ended up digging a grave for the future generation of this beautiful country.

We've completely failed to unlearn the old dictatorship traits and learn to embrace difference. We've failed to learn how to love one another, all we do is force other people to do what we believe in without taking time to understand they "why" bit of it this country is sending people to prison for knowing gay people and not reporting, it's sending people to prison for life for having consensual sex, I even wonder what proof they have? And ignorantly people believe that's a right thing to do.

I wonder what happened to other venues like therapy. No one considers it.
Comment by Devika Mittal on May 13, 2014 at 6:21am

I agree with you Dr. Titus.. very true. In the name of doing 'good', we often end up imposing our thoughts, our biases. 

Comment by Devika Mittal on May 13, 2014 at 6:20am

@Kasiita Alpha I am sorry, I don't seem to get you. How is equal rights binding them? what should they realise? Can you please elaborate

Comment by Dr. Eliezah Titus on May 13, 2014 at 6:18am
Kasiita sound very much like Ugandan. In countries where people live to understand one another, the situation is different. If a parent didn't manage to teach their child what to feel, I don't think any other man can do that. We forget, our parents raised us, they had different tastes and the fact that we don't share similar tastes is evident that we r different but in Uganda and other places where people believe what they like is what's bests for everyone, this doesn't happen.

Am starting to think dictatorship is in our blood and we care less who is affected by our selfish decisions, anywho, I congratulate India, and I pray to God that we here in Africa start growing a love for humanity and embrace it's consequences.
Comment by kasiita Alpha on May 13, 2014 at 5:44am
Well am against this, all we need to do is let these people realise who they are. Claiming that giving them equal rights is not helping them but binding them.

Sponsored Link

Please Pay What You Can to Support PCDN

Please consider Paying What You Can to help PCDN grow. We encourage you to consider any amount from $1 and up. Read the SUPPORT page prior to making a payment to see PCDN's impact and how your payment will help.

Sponsored Link

Translate This Page


PCDN Guidelines and Share Pages

By using this site you're agreeing to the terms of use as outlined in the community guidelines (in particular PCDN is an open network indexed by Google and users should review the privacy options). Please note individual requests for funding or jobs are NOT permitted on the network.

Click BELOW to share site resources Bookmark and Share
or Share on LINKEDIN




© 2016   Created by Craig Zelizer.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service