Peacemaker Afghan President Karzai needs our help in his May 2 Peace conference "Jirag

Afghan President Hamid Karzai has been doing a lot of peace efforts, and needs urgent support for his May 2, 2010, peace gathering, or jirga. Karzai actually met with the local elders in Kandahar and agreed to stop the latest offensive, the US trying to get around it with a slow buildup,

Somehow circumstances made it hard to honor his many peace efforts. When the Soviets left Afghanistan the world didn’t want to admit that a bloodbath was taking place over rebels fighting over who was in charge, thus Karzai’s peace efforts were ignored. He was arrested in 1994 while trying to mediate a cease-fire. Unfortunately instead of Karzai a peacemaker, one has to google "CIA prisoner believed to have rescued Karzai" for the details. His many calls to the Taliban for peace negotiations were usually met with "We won’t negotiate with a traitor" so praising these efforts would convey the idea that the Taliban didn’t want peace, something peace activists would not want to do. Finally the top Taliban supporting warlord Gulbuddin Hekmatyar agreed to comprehensive peace negotiations. Most would prefer that Mullah Omar would be in charge of power sharing. Mullah Omar refused to unequivocally denounce and agree to never to harbor al Qaeda like Hekmatyar agreed to, which is a key US demand and a key Saudi demand, Saudi Arabia somehow involved. Omar has spoke up against al Qaeda tactics with his strict code of ethics, (Google Taliban code of ethics with the NY Times), but Omar won’t specifically denounce bin Laden fearing an attack on shopping bazaars and mosques by al Qaeda getting even, like they are doing in Iraq with the on-going attacks against those Sunnis who ending up changing sides and joined with the Americans. Mullah Omar has been so careful to avoid unnecessary civilian casualties that when the central Afghan bank was failed to be penetrated, the suicide-vested bombers didn’t blow up on the crowded street, instead retreated to the shopping bazaar complex next door, and ordered everyone out instead of shooting at shoppers, holing up for hours, google it with the NY Times for some reluctant praise.

In 2007 Hamid Karzai first urged that the US avoid civilian casualties,

General McChrystal is bragging about less civilian casualties, Hamid Karzai and Mullah Omar are on the same wavelength. The US troops would be more brutal if while wandering around they would be snipped at instead of only in the heat of battle, or while chasing the Taliban.

The US peace movement is fixated on Vietnam War history comparing Karzai with Diem, read their biographies in Wikipedia for their vast differences. Karzai married a women working with Afghan refuges, and definitely doesn’t treat her like a slave. Ngo Dinh Diem represented the small Vietnamese Catholic community, while Karzai represented those who wanted the king to return, the largest anti-Taliban group. Diem wanted to fight with Ho Chi Minh opposing Ho’s Marxist atheism, but ended up attacking Buddhists as well. Karzai preferred to compromise not fight ever since the Russians left. Diem more brutal, not less brutal than his US supporters. Karzai’s recent attempts to compromise a little, with Taliban ethics, is in pursuit of peace. Karzai’s father and one brother was killed by the Taliban for supporting the idea of the king returning. He has as much reason to be full of hate as other Afghans instead he is a sea of if not

Incidentally I won’t let pass, the accusation that Karzai’s brother is an evil drug dealing warlord. Karzai rented property to the CIA and then paid the local Taliban not to attack it, paid them not to attack polling places in the last election etc. Basically the US poured money at him, which he partly gave to the local Taliban to not attack. How drugs fit into the picture I don’t know but we can all see what happens such as in Mexico when no one is throwing money around urging dealers and the police to be less violent, with themselves and each other.

Incidentally I left out how both India and Pakistan both want peace and get in the way of peace while they squabble over whether Afghanistan should be partial to India or Pakistan. However trying to avoid destructive gossip is why other peace sites end up avoiding talking about Hamid Karzai’s peace efforts,

If President Obama listened to the shill parts of the peace movement and just left, and infighting over who was in charge shattered the relative peace civilians are now experiencing with Omar, McChrystal, and Karzai avoiding mayhem, it will be bad news indeed. If the peace movements would help Karzai make peace, it might get Obama back on track of working for a more peaceful world for us all.

Please google, "Western Peace Activists Ignore Real Afghan Peace Efforts"and click on,

By Richard Kane,

Views: 25

Tags: Gulbuddin, Hamid, Hekmatyar, Karzai, Mullah, Omar, RichardKanePA


You need to be a member of Peace and Collaborative Development Network to add comments!

Join Peace and Collaborative Development Network

Comment by RichardKane on June 20, 2011 at 7:58pm

Peace in Afghanistan just could be a few days away if the US would negocitate for temporary attonomy for Kabul.

Comment by RichardKane on May 20, 2010 at 5:43pm
As one of those who spread around Afghan President Karzai’s proposed Peace Jirga as a real hope for the future I reluctantly need to convey some bad news.

While Hamid Karzai who almost got killed in 1994 trying to stop warlords from fighting when the Soviets left, clearly wants peace the Taliban believes it is an insidious US plot to twist the US from heading into bankruptcy into victory. The US and UN now being officially on board doesn’t work when every time he calls for peace the drone war and attacks in Pakistan get worse. Several Tribal leaders who joined the call for a Peace Jarga were assassinated.

I feel a let down as great as when nonviolent activist Tom Fox went to Iraq to declare peace and was beheaded instead.

If is conceivable but not likely that Hamid Karzia can demand a temporary halt to the drone war, with the US not kicking him out of office, and still giving him space for the peace conference to succeed. It is also possible that India, Pakistan, Iran, and Saudi Arabia can get together to end the war. But it is not likely that Afghans who never knew another job but fighter will suddenly look around for a subsidence job, as the supplies and funds given and/or stolen from the Americans stops coming.

The peace advocates killed include Abdul Rahm in April and Rahman Gul along with his two brothers on May 16,

Clearly US President Obama wants a better world and the Afghan quagmire is likely to prevent him from getting it. Everyone from India and Pakistan, through Iran cooperating might end the quagmire, but a bunch of people getting together in Afghanistan, some from all over the world, and demanding peace while ignoring the drone war, I fear will only lead to casualties with those involved.

For details and a lot of related links click on,

Americans are united in wanting the huge spending to stop. Present policy can’t last, but a Republican President like Richard Nixon with his carpet bombing of North Vietnam, might try so-called fighting tough. I fear a possible grim future for more than the Afghans and Americans.
I hope I am not the only one posting at Peace & Collaborative Development Network, who thinks peace sites posting and discussing bad new is important.
Richard Kane

Sponsored Link

Please Pay What You Can to Support PCDN

Please consider Paying What You Can to help PCDN grow. We encourage you to consider any amount from $1 and up. Read the SUPPORT page prior to making a payment to see PCDN's impact and how your payment will help.

Sponsored Link

Translate This Page


PCDN Guidelines and Share Pages

By using this site you're agreeing to the terms of use as outlined in the community guidelines (in particular PCDN is an open network indexed by Google and users should review the privacy options). Please note individual requests for funding or jobs are NOT permitted on the network.

Click BELOW to share site resources Bookmark and Share
or Share on LINKEDIN




© 2016   Created by Craig Zelizer.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service