Ex: Jonathan Power.
Subject: China's growing presence in Africa.
Date: January 22nd. 2013.
Dateline: Dar es Salaam.

Go Into the casino in Tanzania’s capital, Dar Es Salaam and what strikes you? The overwhelming number of players is Chinese. If the Chinese are not quite everywhere in Africa their numbers, their investments and their trade has mushroomed over the last ten years. If one compares Chinese and US investment in Tanzania there is no contest despite Tanzania being one of the US’s favourites.

Overlooked is that China has been in Africa twice before. The first time was also in Tanzania when it came in 1970 complete with workforce and picks and shovels to build a new railway from Dar es Salaam all the way to the Zambian copper belt. For years the railway has been on its uppers, its locomotives and rolling stock ill-maintained and subject to regular breakdowns. The Chinese are now trying to bring it back to life.

Tanzania’s first president, Julius Nyerere, asked by his press secretary, Ben Mkapa, who later himself became president and told me this tale, what Mao had advised him during his visit to China, replied, “Not to create a middle class” and Nyerere didn’t. It was an unconstructive policy that was one of the ingredients in the lack of the country’s economic momentum until Mkapa reversed it.

Unlike the US, France and the UK, China has never tried to establish military alliances or bases in Africa but its provision of arms has been a long standing policy- first as aid to liberation movements and later, as its aid program was wound down in the 1980s, a commercial enterprise. For instance during the Ethiopian/Eritrean war in the late 1990s Beijing sold weapons to both sides and has sold weapons to Zimbabwe.

Now, in its third attempt to engage itself in Africa both the tone and size is different. There are probably a million Chinese living in Africa. China has become a major participant in UN peacekeeping in Africa. A report by the Stockholm Peace Research Institute says that “Chinese peacekeepers are rated among the most professional, well trained, effective and disciplined in UN operations”. (Yet in 1971, when China first took its seat in the Security Council, China opposed all peacekeeping operations which it regarded as interventions in sovereign countries manipulated by the superpowers.)
Five years ago China made a big splash when its Industrial and Commercial Bank bought a 20% stake in South Africa’s highly successful Standard Bank. This was the biggest foreign direct investment in South Africa since the demise of apartheid. This was not “a resources grab” as some critics of China keep accusing it of. It was, as the Financial Times editorialized at the time, “evidence of a deeper relationship.”

The relationship goes on getting deeper. Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala,, the finance minister of Nigeria, tells me that trade between Africa and China increased in value from $11 billion in 2000 to $166 billion last year. Nigeria’s trade with China increased in the same period from $1 billion to $7.8 billion.

According to a new book, “China and Africa” by David Shinn and Joshua Eisenman, “Economic relations between China and Nigeria have grown phenomenally. New deals, investments and agreements occur regularly. [Up to] 600 Chinese companies and joint ventures operate in construction, oil and gas, technology, communications, manufacturing, services and education”.
But Chinese activity is not just at the top end of economic life. In Lagos, Africa’s biggest city, the Chinese trader community lives and works in a large red fortress resembling the Great Wall of China. The estimated Chinese population in Nigeria is 70,000.

Chinese small time traders are to be found in many African countries, often causing resentment as they cut prices and expand businesses at the locals’ expense. In Zambia there were violent riots at a Chinese-owned copper mine over working conditions and pay. The issue became one of the important ones in Zambia’s subsequent general election. In Nigeria their activities have led to the collapse of the textile industry. In Tanzania, where imports from China have been about 15% of its total, Tanzanians complain about the growing number of cheap and counterfeit products. In 2011 the government ordered Chinese foreign traders to return home. But at the same time China’s Export Import Bank signed concessional loans for Tanzania to support the country’s broadband structure and to upgrade Zanzibar’s airport terminal.

China’s purchase of raw materials has become an important export for many countries. China-African trade now accounts for 14% of Africa’s trade and 4% of China’s. It is almost entirely raw materials to feed China’s booming manufacturing- mineral products, in particular iron ore, copper and platinum, base metals, oil, precious stones and wood products. (Much of the timber is illicit, although that is now lessening.)
China will be an important part of Africa’s future. Undoubtedly the relationship will broaden and deepen. Other investors in the West, India and the Arab world will have a hard job keeping up with it.

Copyright Jonathan Power

Views: 610

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

An interesting thought provoking piece, Jonathan. 

could you invite me to attend any of the conferences so I could learn the details first hand Jonathan?


Thank u. I really liked reading through this content

this is a very interesting topic! thank you for sharing Jonathan!

This is an interesting read. China's presence in Africa is transforming the political economy of the African continent and there have consequently been increasingly complicated 'approaches' on 'how' to engage China in this regard. But my position to understanding China in Africa is to ask three interrelated questions. First, what is happening in China in terms of the propellants and hindrances to China's rise (Chinese Domestica)? Second, how does this domestic reality impact and recast China's foreign policy and its ever changing elite philosophy(Chinese internationa)? Third, how should China's foreign policy be equated or differentiated from Sino-Africa relations (Chinese Africana)? This approach has led me to view the current presence of China in Africa from a different perspective to the extent that there is little difference in China's interest in SA's Standard Bank and its interest in AMC or attempt at buying UNOCAL in the US. Also, beyond the ideological underpinnings of Sino-pessimism, Sino-optimism and caution in Sino-Africa realations, there seems to be, as a friend recently told me, some sort of "generational transition" of Sino-African scholarship (particularly from the African side)... It is the ability of African ruling elites and technocrats to understand and/or differentiate the political, theoretical and academic from the developmental intervention that would help in this regard. While South Africa was able to understand that its policy with China created about 25,000 unemployed South Africans in two years, other African states sometimes do not get the 'picture.' Yet Sino-African relations, as Ian Taylor wrote in one of his most instructive books on China in Africa, is the "most momentous event" since the Cold War on the continent. Again, this is an interesting read. Thanks.

Thank you, Jonathan and Abdul-Gafar.

Wow! Great read, Jonathan


Sponsored Link

Please Pay What You Can to Support PCDN

Please consider Paying What You Can to help PCDN grow. We encourage you to consider any amount from $1 and up. Read the SUPPORT page prior to making a payment to see PCDN's impact and how your payment will help.

Sponsored Link

Translate This Page


PCDN Guidelines and Share Pages

By using this site you're agreeing to the terms of use as outlined in the community guidelines (in particular PCDN is an open network indexed by Google and users should review the privacy options). Please note individual requests for funding or jobs are NOT permitted on the network.

Click BELOW to share site resources Bookmark and Share
or Share on LINKEDIN




© 2016   Created by Craig Zelizer.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service